Trade fraud, imported oil blends, and transparency about origin: why buying 100% Italian extra virgin olive oil makes a difference.
There is something special about opening a bottle of 100% ITALIAN extra virgin olive oil.
The aroma of freshly harvested olives, the herbaceous and vegetal notes, the bold taste, and that pleasant spicy sensation in the throat tell the story of the richness of the land and a millennia-old tradition.
Yet today, one question deserves to be asked: how much can we really trust the extra virgin olive oil we buy?
Extra virgin olive oil is one of the most representative products of Italian agri-food excellence. It is appreciated worldwide for its organoleptic characteristics and its connection to Mediterranean culture. But it is also one of the products most exposed to the risk of trade fraud.
Growing international demand, harvest fluctuations, price competition, and increasingly complex supply chains have encouraged unfair trade practices, sometimes difficult to detect even for the most attentive consumers.
For L'Acropoli di Puglia, where the Lucarella family has been producing extra virgin olive oil since 1889, knowing what you buy is as important as appreciating what you put on the table.
And it all starts with one fundamental word: ORIGIN.
The hidden side of the EVOO market: recent trade fraud
Fraud in the olive oil sector does not only consist in selling a product of lower quality. In the most serious cases, it involves practices that deliberately deceive the consumer regarding the product category, composition, traceability, or geographical origin of the olive oil.
Recent operations carried out in Italy show how important it is to remain vigilant.
On October 31, 2026, the Ministry of Agriculture announced two major operations in Tuscany, which led to the seizure of over 450 quintals of irregular oil.
In the first intervention, 165 quintals of oil marketed as extra virgin olive oil were seized, which turned out to lack the necessary traceability and had been obtained from processing residues.
In a second operation, about 300 quintals of oil of foreign origin were intercepted. Laboratory analyses confirmed that the product did not meet the necessary requirements to be classified as extra virgin, despite being intended for sale under that designation.
Another significant case emerged in February 2026. The Carabinieri seized about 18.1 tons of oil intended for sale in Canada. The product had been declared and labeled as extra virgin olive oil, but laboratory analyses confirmed that it was actually virgin olive oil. The investigators also found inconsistencies between the declared origin, which could be traced back to the European Union, and the actual composition of the blend, which contained oils from both European and non-European origins.
These events are added to an important report published in January 2026 by the European Court of Auditors, which highlighted some critical issues in the application of controls on olive oil in the countries of the European Union. Among the issues reported were deficiencies in traceability and in checks on some oils imported from third countries.
These episodes highlight a fundamental problem: the words "Extra Virgin" and "Italian" on a bottle must correspond to real and verifiable characteristics, not simply be expressions used for commercial purposes.
Italian oil and imported oil: what is the real difference?
It is important to clarify one aspect: imported oil is not necessarily low-quality or fraudulent. Spain, Greece, Portugal, and other Mediterranean countries produce excellent extra virgin olive oils.
The problem is not geographical origin itself, but the correspondence between the declared origin, the actual quality, and the product's production history.
The difference becomes particularly important when we compare an authentic 100% Italian extra virgin olive oil with a commercial blend obtained from oils coming from different countries.
Consider two different products.
A 100% Italian extra virgin olive oil
-
The olives are grown and harvested in Italy.
-
The olives are milled in Italy.
-
The oil comes exclusively from Italian olives and has a traceable production chain.
-
The quality must meet all the chemical and organoleptic parameters required for the extra virgin category.
- The geographical origin can be verified through documentation and production and traceability records.
A blend of imported oils or oils from different origins
-
It may contain oils obtained from olives coming from different countries.
-
It may be composed of oils from different olive varieties and olive-growing seasons.
-
The organoleptic characteristics may vary depending on the composition of the blend.
-
It can be perfectly legal and suitable for consumption, provided it is produced and marketed in compliance with regulations and correctly labeled.
-
It cannot legitimately be presented as 100% Italian if the olives or oils used come from other countries.
One particularly important aspect concerns bottling: bottling an oil in Italy does not automatically mean producing Italian oil.
An oil obtained from imported olives or a blend of oils from different origins does not become 100% Italian simply because the final packaging takes place in an Italian facility.
European regulations establish precise indications about the origin of olive oil. On labels, we can find, for example, wording such as:
-
Olive oil of Italian origin.
-
Blend of olive oils originating from the European Union.
-
Blend of olive oils not originating from the European Union.
-
Blend of olive oils originating from the European Union and not originating from the European Union.
These are different and non-interchangeable indications. Learning to read them is one of the simplest ways to make an informed purchase.
Why does a 100% Italian extra virgin oil have a different value?
Producing an Italian extra virgin olive oil means much more than harvesting and pressing olives.
It means taking care of the olive groves, scheduling the harvest, quickly transporting the olives to the mill, carefully monitoring the extraction phases, and storing the product under the most appropriate conditions.
Every step contributes to determining the final quality.
Italian olive growing is also characterized by an extraordinary biodiversity of cultivars, landscapes, and local traditions. From the delicate aromas of oils from Northern Italy to the intense, fruity, and spicy notes of many Southern productions, every territory expresses a particular identity.
In Puglia, and especially in the Valle d'Itria, the olive tree is an integral part of the landscape, history, and culture.
The Coratina cultivar, for example, is appreciated for its intense fruitiness, characteristic green notes, bitterness, and spiciness. These sensory peculiarities are also associated with the natural presence of phenolic compounds.
An extra virgin oil is not simply a cooking ingredient. It is an agricultural product with its own identity, a precise harvest season, and a story that deserves to be told.
And it is precisely this story that we must protect.
How to recognize a true extra virgin olive oil
It is not necessary to be a professional taster to learn how to choose a good extra virgin olive oil.
There are some aspects that every consumer should check before purchasing.
1. Check the origin
Carefully read the declaration of origin stated on the label. If you want to buy Italian oil, it is important to check that the product explicitly declares the Italian origin of the olives and the oil, without confusing the origin with the mere place of bottling.
2. Check the harvest information
The indication of the vintage or olive-growing season is valuable information. Freshness is important because, over time, oil gradually loses some of its aromatic and qualitative characteristics.
3. Choose transparent and traceable producers
When possible, buy directly from producers who can tell you where the olives grow, when they are harvested, and how the oil is produced.
4. Pay attention to the packaging
Dark glass bottles, cans, and other suitable containers help protect the oil from exposure to light. It is also important to store it away from heat sources and excessive exposure to oxygen.
5. Know the meaning of the extra virgin category
Extra virgin is a regulated product category. It is not simply a commercial designation used to indicate a premium product.
The oil must meet certain chemical parameters and pass an organoleptic evaluation carried out by a recognized tasting panel.
An oil may appear pleasant to the eye and have a pleasant aroma, but still not meet all the necessary requirements to be classified as extra virgin.
6. Be wary of excessively low prices
Producing a quality extra virgin oil requires agricultural investments, labor, harvesting, milling, storage, and packaging.
A particularly low price should therefore prompt the consumer to check the origin and quality of the product more carefully.
L'Acropoli di Puglia: growing while respecting tradition
For the Lucarella family, extra virgin olive oil has never been just a commercial product.
Our story begins in 1889, when Domenico Lucarella gave life to the family's olive oil tradition in Martina Franca, in the heart of Puglia.
Today, after several generations, we continue to safeguard this legacy with a precise goal: to preserve the identity of our production by progressively improving working methods and quality standards.
We believe that tradition and innovation should not compete. On the contrary, they must proceed together.
Our commitment develops mainly along three lines.
1. Hygiene, food safety, and production standards
The modern food market requires producers to follow increasingly rigorous procedures regarding hygiene and safety.
In our mill, we consider compliance with applicable European regulations on hygiene and food safety a fundamental element of our growth journey.
This means paying particular attention to the cleanliness of the production environments and equipment, the correct management of the olives and oil, storage conditions, product traceability, and contamination prevention.
We work to consolidate our procedures in line with internationally recognized food safety principles, including the HACCP system, while keeping our production processes consistent with the requirements set by European regulations.
For us, quality is not just something perceived on the palate. It is a value that must be protected at every stage of production.
2. Respect for the olive trees and the environment
A great extra virgin olive oil is born long before the olives reach the mill.
It is born in the olive grove.
We believe that respecting the olive tree is essential to obtain a product capable of authentically expressing the character of our territory.
Responsible pruning, careful harvesting, and proper agronomic management help preserve the health and productivity of the trees.
We pay particular attention to harvesting techniques that minimize damage to branches and fruit. The timing of the harvest is also crucial: identifying the most suitable period helps preserve the aromatic and sensory characteristics of the olives.
Our philosophy is simple: the olive tree should not be considered merely a source of production, but a living part of our agricultural and cultural heritage.
3. Authenticity and traceability of production
In a market where commercial blends and international supply chains are increasingly widespread, we believe that transparency represents one of the most important values a producer can offer.
Our goal is to allow customers to clearly know the identity of our oils, their production process, and their characteristics.
From the olive grove to the mill, from storage to bottling, traceability is an essential element of our working method.
We want those who buy L'Acropoli di Puglia to know they are choosing a product linked to a true Italian agricultural and productive tradition.
Our ambition is not simply to produce more. It is to grow responsibly, improve our standards, and preserve what makes our oil recognizable.
The difference you can taste: discovering the Lucarella family's oils.
Every extra virgin oil has its own personality. The timing of the harvest, the olive varieties, and the production choices help create different aromas, flavors, and sensations.
We enhance these differences through a selection of EVOO that tells different expressions of the Puglian olive oil tradition.
Your choice matters: we protect the future of true 100% ITALIAN extra virgin olive oil
Every time a consumer chooses an ITALIAN and traceable product, they support much more than a single producer.
They support olive growers, agricultural workers, traditional mills, rural communities, and a cultural heritage passed down from generation to generation.
The future of quality extra virgin olive oil also depends on informed consumers who are capable of asking questions, reading labels, and understanding the value hidden behind what they buy.
We are proud of our roots in Martina Franca and of a family tradition that has continued since 1889.
We look to the future with the determination to improve, innovate, and protect what truly matters: the authenticity of our EVOO, respect for the land, and the trust of our customers.
Because a true ITALIAN extra virgin olive oil should not only taste like Italy. It must have a 100% Italian origin, a traceable production history, and a producer ready to stand behind the quality of every bottle.
